Last week my husband and I were traveling in the Finger Lakes region of western New York State. I used to live in the area some seventeen years ago, when I was a graduate student in Ithaca. At that time most New York wines were pretty bad. There were a few exceptions, but on the whole wines from the area were cheap, sweet and simple. Wine cooler fodder, if you remember that mercifully brief fad.
Well times have changed, baby. Throughout a single day of tasting I kept having a strong feeling of dislocation. “Wait a minute—is this Napa Valley?” The wines were delicious, with absolutely nothing to apologize for. The tasting rooms were lovely, making the most of the glorious scenery. The winery staff people doing the pouring were proud of their product and good ambassadors for the region. I can’t wait to go back and continue my explorations of the many small producers that are making a name for themselves.
Our first visit of the day was to the Dr. Konstantin Frank vineyard, named for its founder, on the shores of Keuka Lake. Dr. Frank, a Ukrainian immigrant, was an early booster of the region and a pioneer in cultivating the European vinifera grape. Before his experiments in the sixties, the region was known only for its American grapes, like Concord and Delaware. While these grapes are fine for juice, they make terrible wine. Dr. Frank was convinced that he could grow the fine winemaking varieties even in a climate as challenging as that of upstate New York. Together with other pioneers at Cornell University and the Gold Seal Winery, he proved it could be done and made possible the growth of a new wine-producing region.
My husband and I had resolved we would only buy wines that were special in some way. By that we meant no wines that could be produced better elsewhere. I didn’t want wine that was pretty good for a New York wine, but wine that was worth drinking no matter where it was from. I thought that would be a pretty tough standard based on my past experience with the region, but instead we found ourselves struggling to narrow down the list as the tasting progressed and we grew more and more impressed. We know before we went that the Dr. Frank cellars are renowned for their German-style Rieslings. But when we found ourselves exclaiming over a subtle and delicate Pinot Noir, we knew we weren’t in Kansas anymore. Delicious red wine from a New York grower? Impossible!
After much debate, we came out with two cases. One full case was a non-vintage white blend under the Salmon Run label, which the Dr. Frank company creates using other growers’ wines. This Cold Brook White was a pleasant, off-dry blend of chardonnay and Riesling with a slight flinty undertaste I particularly associate with New York. I don’t think you’d mistake it for the product of anywhere else, which meant it fit our requirements. I look forward to pairing it with a wide range of food, and at $7 per bottle it will make a great every day table wine. The second case was a mixture of more refined wines under the Dr. Konstantin Frank label. We came home with the Dr. Frank Dry Riesling (2004), the Johannisberg Riesling (2004) and the Pinot Noir (2001). The Dry Riesling is a multiple-award winner, and it fully lived up to billing. Very dry, with little residual sweetness, it still had lots of fruit taste and a very winning delicacy. The Johannisberg Riesling I liked even better, which surprised me because I don’t usually care for semi-dry wines. This, though, had a roundness and a balance that was simply delicious. I can’t wait to pair this somewhat flowery wine with a simple meal of roast chicken.
The big surprise, as I’ve mentioned, was the 2001 Pinot Noir. At more than $21 per bottle, we felt we were paying a bit of a “pinot premium” (thank you “Sideways” for ruining pinot prices for next three years). Nevertheless, the medium body, berry fruitiness and clean finish made me think this will go beautifully with duck or a mild lamb. I wouldn’t bet on New York being able to produce a red this good in every year, but that vintage impressed the heck out of me.
A mere mile and a half down the road towards the small town of Hammondsport is the equally well-known Heron Hill winery. Heron Hill grows much the same variety of grapes as Dr. Frank on the same slopes by the lake, but the effect in the bottle couldn’t be more different. Here the standout was a Chardonnay. We’d tasted two Chardonnays at Dr. Frank and felt they were fine, but nothing special. Heron Hill’s Ingle Vineyard Chardonnay (2002) was fantastic, in contrast. Aged in European oak, the wine had vanilla warmth mellowed by a moderate buttery smoothness without being in the least bit gooey. We thought it was well worth the $15 price point. Our other favorite was the Riesling Reserve 25th Anniversary Vintage (2002). Bone dry and unbelievably delicate, I’d be very careful pairing this wine with any kind of food. It has a delicious austerity that could easily be overwhelmed. I plan to serve it as an aperitif, and only with my favorite fellow wine snobs. The rest of our case was filled out by a blend we were quite taken with, the Eclipse White 2003. Mostly Chardonnay and Sauvignon Blanc, the wine has 15% Pinot Gris. Yet the Pinot Gris is at the forefront of the taste, making the wine taste like an excellent Italian Pinot Grigio, without a trace of the harshness that sometimes mars that style of wine. This wine will be terrific with light pasta dishes and white-fleshed fish.
By this time we had tasted and discussed a total of eighteen wines at the two wineries. Making our selections for the case we purchased took extensive and very pleasurable debate. Once we’d loaded the back of the car with our booty from Heron Hill, joining the two cases already there from Dr. Frank’s, we were done for the day. On to Hammondsport for a leisurely lunch at a sidewalk table beside the town green, and then a scenic drive back to our bed and breakfast.
I can’t wait to go back to the region to visit the many well-respected wineries we weren’t able to see this time: Fox Run, Hermann Wiemer, Wagner (famous for its Ice Wine), Chateau Lafayette-Reneau and a few others. Next time I’ll allow at least four days for roaming and tasting. And now to plan the dinner party!